Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Doubles in Death

According to Stark House Press, William O'Farrell (1904-1962) was born in St. Louis and moved with his family to Pittsburgh at the age of 11. By 16, O'Farrell had dropped out of school to work on the Pittsburgh Post, then began traveling in Europe when he turned 18. Before becoming a full-time novelist, O'Farrell worked as a Merchant Seaman and an actor. He wrote suspense and crime fiction while also writing for television shows like Perry Mason, Alfred Hitchcock Presents, and Thriller. His 1942 breakout novel, Repeat Performance, was filmed in 1947 and his short story, "Over There, Darkness", which won an Edgar Award, was filmed as an episode of Alfred Hitchcock Presents.

Stark House has been reprinting O'Farrell's novels, including the aforementioned Repeat Performance. Recently, the publisher released new editions of two O'Farrell novels, The Devil His Due, originally published by Berkley in 1957, and Doubles in Death, published by Perma in 1955 (writing as William Grew). The two are included in one volume with a scholarly introduction by the great Curtis Evans. I chose to read Doubles in Death based on the promise of a "fatal attraction" style.

Alan is a thirty-year-old manager working at an established advertising firm in New York City. He's happily married and living a quiet workaholic suburban lifestyle just outside of the city. He frequently has his lunch at the same diner, just a few blocks from his employer. Repeatedly, he sees the same lone woman, Lily, in the diner eating lunch. He notices that she also works as a secretary for another agency in his building. Her homely demeanor is an attraction. Alan approaches her, and the two have lunch together multiple times. Eventually, Alan and Lily gravitate to weekend lunch at a nice restaurant. That's when Alan realizes Lily isn't worth risking his marriage, employment, and social status. He breaks off the newfound friendship with Lily, and that should be the end of it. But it never ends that easily, right?

Lily continues to pester Alan at work, dropping by unannounced and even calling him at his home. Alan confesses to his wife Judy that he had lunch with Lily, but that was the extent of their relationship. Despite multiple warnings, Lily won't go away. In steps another obsessive lunatic in Merle.

Merle works in the mailroom at Alan's place of employment. Merle is attracted to Alan's style - work office, suit-and-tie, nice watch, the up-and-up. Merle is a jealous maniac with a class fixation and a hankering for shortcutting his way into the white-collar role. As he stalks Alan, he quickly picks up that Lily and Alan are, or were, a thing. After stealing Alan's watch, Merle makes a deadly move on Lily before targeting Alan's wife. In this nightmare scenario, Alan is left with "doubles in death", two crazy stalkers affecting his work and home life.

In his excellent intro, Evans points out that O'Farrell's writing is compelling in the way it transforms pulpy crime elements through "richly detailed background, into an unusually cohesive and convincing product." He nailed the aura of this novel. It's compelling as Hell, a quick, absorbing read that sort of sticks with you long after you've read the last page. It's a fatal attraction concept, but doubled with a tremendous heaping of two stark, invasive personalities - Lily's need for companionship and Merle's desire for power and control. Early on, I felt animosity toward Alan and his extramarital search for happiness. By the novel's end, that feeling morphed into an anxious, heartfelt wish that Alan and his young family survived the crazy ordeal. There are enough twists and turns to keep the pages flipping fast and furious.

As a workplace thriller, domestic intrigue, or home invasion, O'Farrell has all of the suspense tropes covered. It's clever, plot-propulsive, and possesses a detailed characterization that allows for evolution even with a short page count. Doubles in Death is fantastic and worth every penny. Highly recommended. Get the book HERE.

No comments:

Post a Comment